MLB The Show 25 is a baseball game that includes all the outstanding players from the last century to this century. You can either form a team you support or form a dream team with the best active players. You can even gather retired legends to form a legendary team.
There are many positions in baseball. If you want to form a legendary and powerful team, each player must be strong enough. Now let’s have a look at the most excellent players in each position.
Catcher

- Mike Piazza, 92 OVR All-Star
- Jorge Posada, 92 OVR Standout
- Ted Simmons, 90 OVR Awards
- Carlos Santana, 92 OVR Spotlight
- Bo Naylor, 92 OVR Color Storm
Mike Piazza’s baseball career started with Dodgers in 1996 and ended with Mets in 2008. Although he is a catcher, he has hit 427 home runs in his career.
He is currently the best catcher, but he cannot play as a designated hitter, which makes his value very low, only 11,000 MLB The Show 25 stubs.
First Baseman
- Gil Hodges, 99 OVR Hall of Fame
- Jeimer Candelario, 91 OVR Moonshot
- Don Baylor, 91 OVR Standout
- Willie Stargell, 90 OVR Contributor
- Stan Musial, 88 OVR All-Star
The best first baseman is naturally Gil Hodges, and his super high attributes make it difficult to dispute. Whether it is offense or defense, he is the best.
But you know it’s hard to get this card, so we’ll settle for the next best thing and choose the easier cards in the top five, which are Jeimer Candelario and Willie Stargell. Both cards can be obtained through MLB The Show 25 stubs trading, but Jeimer Candelario is more valuable, around 140,000 stubs, and Willie Stargell is 1/14 of him. You can make a choice based on your assets.
Second Baseman
- Brian Dozier, 93 OVR 2nd Half Heroes
- Jason Kipnis, 92 OVR Prime
- Chase Utley, 91 OVR All-Star
- Jake Cronenworth, 9 OVR2 Color Storm
- Brian Roberts, 91 OVR Moonshot
Brian Dozier announced his retirement in 2021, ending his eight-year career in the major leagues. Brian Dozier is good at hitting, and his performance in fielding is also good, but his speed is mediocre.
As the current top-ranked second baseman in MLB 25, you only need 15,000 stubs to get this card.
Third Baseman
- Scott Rolen, 99 OVR Awards
- José Ramírez, 91 OVR Live
- Chase Headley, 93 OVR 2nd Half Heroes
- Willi Castro, 93 OVR Topps Now
- Mark Vientos, 91 OVR Color Storm
A seven-time All-Star and eight-time Gold Glove winner, Scott Rolen is an undisputed star on the field. But completing his collection is difficult, and as an alternative, you can choose José Ramírez, who is good at hitting but weak on defense.
Left Fielder
- Yordan Alvarez, 92 OVR All-Star
- Aaron Judge, 93 OVR Live
- Lou Brock, 91 OVR Moonshot
- Jung Hoo Lee, 91 OVR Color Storm
- Willie Stargell, 90 OVR Contributor
Yordan Alvarez has won many honors since entering the major leagues in 2022. He has been selected as an All-Star for three consecutive years.
Yordan Alvarez can only play as a left fielder in MLB 25. He is very good at hitting and is also a rare left-handed hitter. The value of this card is about 110,000 stubs. If you don’t have many stubs, you can also exchange it for Lou Brock, who is worth about 7,000 stubs.

Right Fielder
- Carlos Beltran, 99 OVR Signature
- Shohei Ohtani, 91 OVR Live
- Aaron Judge, 93 OVR Live
- Ronald Acuña Jr., 94 OVR All-Star
- George Springer, 93 OVR Standout
Right fielders have too many stars and each one is priced too high to be considered. If you can’t get one of these dominant players, then George Springer at 52,000 stubs is the last resort.
Center Fielder
- Carlos Beltran, 99 OVR Signature
- George Springer, 93 OVR Standout
- George Springer, 93 OVR Ranked 1000
- Byron Buxton, 92 OVR Moonshot
- Bernie Williams, 92 OVR Postseason
Center fielders don’t have as many stars, and three of the top five are untradable. If George Springer is already your right fielder, then choose Bernie Williams as your center fielder.
Shortstop
- Bobby Witt Jr., 91 OVR Live
- Honus Wagner, 91 OVR 20th Anniversary
- Willi Castro, 93 OVR Topps Now
- Ezequiel Tovar, 91 OVR Color Storm
- Trevor Story, 92 OVR Standout
Some of the above are top-notch in terms of hitting, speed and defense. If you can’t sign Bobby Witt Jr. and Willi Castro, then choose Trevor Story.
Designated Hitter
- Carlos Beltran, 99 OVR Signature
- Gil Hodges, 99 OVR Hall of Fame
- Scott Rolen, 99 OVR Awards
- José Ramírez, 91 OVR Live
- Shohei Ohtani, 91 OVR Live
This position is also full of stars. José Ramírez is the best designated hitter that ordinary players can get, with the first three 99 OVR monsters.
Starting Pitcher
- Roger Clemens, 99 OVR Awards
- Tarik Skubal, 89 OVR Live
- Pedro Martinez, 93 OVR All-Sta
- Pedro Martinez, 93 OVR Ranked 1000
- Jordan Zimmermann, 92 OVR Milestone
The starting pitcher is the most important part of the team’s defense. Fortunately, except for Roger Clemens, the conditions for obtaining excellent starting pitchers are not harsh. You need to prepare about 54,000 stubs to get a top pitcher.
Relief Pitcher/Closing Pitcher
- Eric Gagne, 92 OVR All-Star
- Ben Joyce, 91 OVR Color Storm
- Andrés Muñoz, 91 OVR Spotlight
- Dennis Eckersley, 92 OVR Awards
- Lucas Erceg, 89 OVR Egg Hunt
There are many good relief pitchers, but the good news is that they are usually not very valuable. Even Eric Gagne, who is currently ranked first, only costs about 20,000 stubs.
If you have enough stubs, choose from the above players and build your team!






