In MLB The Show 26's Diamond Dynasty, the efficiency of your card deck building directly determines your competitiveness in online matches. For players who don't invest real money, acquiring each card requires a trade-off between time cost and practical benefits.
While the update pace of MLB 26 content pool has slowed down, there are still several cost-effective cards worth prioritizing. This guide ranks cards in reverse order of practical value, analyzing the acquisition method, core data, and usage scenarios for each card from fifth to first place.
Tier List
- Fifth Place: Ian Happ
- Fourth Place: Adrian Morejon
- Third Place: Corbin Burnes
- Second Place: Elly De La Cruz
- First Place: José Ramírez

Fifth Place: Ian Happ
In MLB 26, Ian Happ has a relatively short replacement cycle, but he remains an ideal choice for mid-game transition. He can be unlocked for free by completing all objectives in Cityscapes program. It is recommended to prioritize repetitive challenges to reduce time costs.
He possesses switch-hitting ability, showing no significant weaknesses against either left- or right-handed pitchers. His 73 vision reduces high-flying ball swing percentage, and he can play left field, second base, third base, center field, and right field.
He is suitable for use on the bench as a backup for multiple positions, or as a temporary replacement for a struggling to start second base pitcher. Investing in mods or training points is not recommended.
Fourth Place: Adrian Morejon
Relief pitchers typically struggle to make the must-have list in MLB The Show 26, but Adrien breaks the mold with his pitch combination and consistency in crucial situations. The card is free and comes from Mural Series.
Adrian Morejon's sinker features an outlier, a speed of 98-99 mph, and a 98 circle change break, creating a significant speed advantage against left-handed hitters. He also has a slider and curveball, forming a 5-Pitch Max.
119-point clutch significantly improves pitching accuracy in ties or when leading by one run, making it reliable in close games.
In terms of usage, it's recommended to use it after the seventh inning against consecutive left-handed hitters, avoiding pitching more than one inning.
Tactically, use Sinker to get the ball first, then use Circle Change to induce a swing miss; if the opponent primarily hits right-handed, prioritize using Slider to attack low outside corners.
Third Place: Corbin Burnes
Corbin Burnes' value in MLB The Show 26 lies in its extremely low acquisition threshold and consistent performance in actual gameplay. It can be obtained for free through Inning XP Path or acquired directly for approximately 5,000 MLB The Show 26 Stubs.
Although Sinker lacks a speed tag, its 75 break combined with a 95 mph pitch speed makes its base-reaching trajectory more unpredictable than the data suggests; its relatively low control is a weakness, and it's recommended to equip the control mod after upgrading to P5.
In All-Star mode, he's easily targeted by high-level hitters, making him more suitable for Hall of Fame or against mid-level opponents.
His pitching primarily consists of drop shots and sliders, with no more than three circle changes per inning, avoiding repetitive use of the same pitch (especially curveballs).
Second Place: Elly De La Cruz
Elly De La Cruz is rated slightly below top-tier cards in MLB 26, but his versatility keeps him firmly in the starting lineup. He's obtainable through the market, and his price has dropped to a reasonable range.
The optimal setup is without any mods, relying solely on his base stats and dispersed P5. Balanced fundamental stats are key; over-specialization sacrifices adaptability.
With a clutch performance and defensive prowess, Elly De La Cruz is capable of playing shortstop, second base, and third base.
If you acquire a higher-rated shortstop, you can move Elly De La Cruz to second or third base. His arm strength is sufficient to handle long passes from third base, while he excels in reaction play at second base. No other card in his price range can completely replace him in the short term.
First Place: José Ramírez
José Ramírez is a top-tier collectible reward from Mural Series in MLB The Show 26. While the acquisition cost is high, his practical value justifies the investment. He combines switch-hitting, multi-position defense, and top-tier swing.
You can accumulate funds by grinding MLB The Show 26 Stubs on Diamond Quest and selling tradeable cards. His swing is excellent, far exceeding his stats, and his switch-hitting has no disadvantage against either side.
José Ramírez can play left field, second base, and shortstop. Placing him on the left field maximizes his arm strength and reduces defensive pressure on the infield. If infield reinforcement is needed, moving him to second base will cover the area slightly to the right of the center line.
It's recommended to reserve a fixed position for him and avoid frequent rotations.
The above five cards cover the most important targets for free-to-play players in the current version of MLB The Show 26. By following the above path and strategy, a competitive Diamond Dynasty lineup can be built without investing real money.















