Faced with so many MLB The Show 25 player cards, not only do you as a player not know how to choose the best, but the game itself also needs to regularly integrate and classify them to make the entire MLB 25 player system clearer and more organized.
This classification can be divided into stars or rookies according to player popularity, or offensive or defensive according to player specialties, or random themes can be arranged, just so that you can get a new player selection experience!
However, no matter how you choose the card, you must complete specific tasks or consume MLB The Show 25 stubs. In order to allow you to better plan your stubs and game time, we will take Jolt cards as an example to recommend you 10 best options.

1. Junior Caminero
- Rays 3B
- OVR: 75
- Quirk: Rally Monkey
- Availability: 100 Stubs
If you’re looking for a player with a well-rounded stat line, but with a lot of speed and fielding, Caminero is the guy for you. His fielding in the 50s and 60s is enough to make him a versatile player at multiple infield positions.
While Caminero may not offer the same offensive power as some of the star players when playing Diamond Dynasty, his long-term reliability is enough to make him a cornerstone of your team.
2. George Brett
- Royals 3B
- OVR: 85
- Quirks: Homebody, Fighter, Dead Red
- Availability: Team Affinity
As a reliable hitter, Brett’s advantage is that he has a high contact rate with both hands, while most players at the same position are usually only good with one hand. In addition, his vision and discipline, stats are also very good.
If possible, it is recommended that you place Brett at third base, which can not only threaten the opposing team, but also allow Brett to better cooperate with his own players, bringing more exciting main performances in Diamond Dynasty.
3. Max Muncy
- Dodgers SS
- OVR: 99
- Power vs RHP: 100
- Availability: Team Affinity
Sometimes when arranging a team lineup, you may not know where to put a player, but if there is a player who can play multiple positions at the same time, this problem is easy to solve! And Muncy is such a player.
Muncy is not only capable of playing first base and third base, but also has a smooth and powerful swing and strong attacking power against both right-handed and left-handed. Although his contact rating is lower in comparison, he is still a player worth recruiting.
4. Ian Kinsler
- Rangers 2B
- OVR: 99
- Clutch: 125
- Availability: Team Affinity
Kinsler is a well-rounded player with balanced attributes and skills. With a perfect blend of speed, defense, and contact rating, Kinsler can help you set the tone for your team during games and be reliable enough to ensure stability at second base.
In addition, Kinsler’s versatility allows him to flexibly respond to different game situations, increasing your chances of turning the tide at critical moments, while also being able to serve as a starter or defender.
5. Frank Thomas
- White Sox 1B
- OVR: 86
- Quirks: First Pitch Hitter, Night Player, Bad Ball Hitter
- Availability: Team Affinity
As an already powerful hitter, Thomas can become even more offensive in MLB 25 with effective quirks, instantly destroying the opponent’s defense based on high contact and power ratings.
Unfortunately, while Thomas has reliable offensive power, his defensive ability is very average. But to be honest, this is nothing. As long as you have enough MLB 25 stubs, you can let Thomas guarantee your hits and score, and then recruit other defensive players.

6. Andrew McCutchen
- Pirates RF
- OVR: 85
- Quirk: Bad Ball Hitter
- Availability: Team Affinity
With a solid contact rate and excellent defensive ability, McCutchen is enough to bring you wonderful performance in the center field position, and in Diamond Dynasty, he can combine key attributes such as speed, contact and defense to help his teammates.
7. Justin Martinez
- Diamondbacks CP
- OVR: 76
- Quirk: Outlier 1
- Availability: 125 Stubs
If you choose Martinez as your team pitcher, you will have more options on the mound with his split ball and slider, as well as a fast base run score with his pitching speed of up to 99.
In the game, Martinez can not only effectively fight against the opponent’s right-handed hitters, but also have the opportunity to utilize more ground balls and strikeouts to improve the team’s score.
8. Rollie Fingers
- Brewers CP
- OVR: 85
- Quirk: Stopper
- Availability: Team Affinity
This is also a strong pitcher who will perform better when you match him with the most suitable pitching interface. It is worth mentioning that if Fingers is sent to the field late in the game, he will be able to stop the opponent’s offense in Diamond Dynasty mode and effectively deal with lefties and righties.
9. Kyle Schwarber
- Phillies DH
- OVR: 81
- Quirks: Breaking Ball Hitter, Road Warrior, Table Setter
- Availability: 331 Stubs
Although both left and right hand strengths are as high as 96/97, Schwarber’s advantage is still concentrated in his left hand. With Breaking Ball Hitter or Road Warrior and the ability to attack quickly, Schwarber will have a stronger offensive power in MLB 25.
10. Babe Ruth
- Yankees RF
- OVR: 85
- Quirk: Unfazed
- Availability: Team Affinity
Ruth can provide you with the strongest combat power and flexibility in both on-field performance and team lineup arrangement. His high touch rate and power rating enable him to fight against the opponent and also serve as a right fielder and first baseman at the same time, making him a model of offensive solid ball player.
I believe you have discovered that among these players, those with balanced attributes lack outstanding advantages and explosiveness, and those who are good at offense/defense are likely to be not good at the other, so you need to recruit them according to your team’s current arrangements to maximize the team’s strength. Thank you for reading.






