In WoW TBC Classic Anniversary event, players in Shattrath City face a crucial decision: whether to pledge allegiance to Aldor or Scryers. This choice will directly affect your character's progression path, gear acquisition pace, and more.
The actual benefits gained from these two factions vary significantly depending on the class and specialization. Some have negligible effects, while others can significantly influence gear choices.
This guide will analyze the differences between Aldor and Scryers by class and specialization to help you make the best choice for yourself early in WoW TBC Classic Anniversary.
Druid
Balance
For Balance, the overall strength difference between Aldor and Scryers is not significant; the choice depends more on gear details.
In Phase 1 BiS gear selection, Scryers' Scryer's Bloodgem can help you reach your spell hit cap more easily. If you don't choose this gear, you'll need to choose other gear with at least 8% hit chance, as Balance only gains 4% hit chance through talents.
If you choose Aldor, you'll need to compensate for hit rating with gems or other equipment.
Regarding shoulder enchantments, Aldor's Greater Inscription of Discipline is slightly better than Scryers'. As for trinkets, while Scryers can eventually create their own runic spellthread through tailoring pick-up, Aldor's Shattered Sun Pendant of Acumen is superior in the long run.
Therefore, overall, Aldor has a slight advantage in the future.
Feral DPS
Unlike most other specs in TBC Classic, Feral DPS is almost unaffected by faction choice. The two factions offer shoulder enchantments: Aldor's Greater Inscription of Vengeance and Scryers' Greater Inscription of the Blade.
Despite different stat distributions, simulations show that their output performance is essentially identical. Overall, Aldor theoretically has a slight advantage, but the difference is minimal, and you can choose based on your personal preference.
Feral Tank
Feral Tanks are also unaffected by faction selection. Tank shoulder enchants from Aldor and Scryers performs extremely similarly in threat and survivability, with negligible differences.
Therefore, you can confidently choose based on preference, reputation acquisition cost, etc.
Restoration
Restoration clearly favors Aldor. Aldor's Greater Inscription of Faith significantly outperforms Scryers' Greater Inscription of the Oracle to heal output.
Furthermore, choosing to tailor Restoration grants Golden Spellthread from Aldor, further enhancing its benefits. Therefore, from a practical standpoint, Aldor is the optimal Restoration choice.
Hunter
The difference in faction selection for Hunters is not significant, but for those seeking maximum optimization, Aldor has a slight edge.
Aldor's Greater Inscription of Vengeance is numerically slightly better than Scryers' Greater Inscription of the Blade. Meanwhile, Hunter's BiS gear utilizes Aldor's rings, giving Aldor a slight advantage in the early game.
Mage
For Mage, the choice of faction is not crucial; it won't substantially affect their damage output.
Therefore, you can freely choose your preferred faction.
Paladin
Holy
Holy's choice is more a matter of personal preference. Aldor's shoulder enchant offers slightly better healing, while Scryers have a slight advantage in spell critical strikes.
However, considering the entire expansion cycle, Aldor is better in terms of pure healers, giving them a slight edge.
Protection
Protection is clearly more suitable for Scryers in the early game. Scryers can more easily improve their reputation, and shoulder enchant offers slightly better crit immunity and dodge.
Furthermore, Scryers' Scryer's Bloodgem, Seer's Signet, and Thalodien's Charm are all excellent early-game tank gear, while Aldor's tank chest is more easily replaced. In summary, Scryers is a more reliable choice for Protection.
Retribution
If you're aiming for maximum damage output and late-game value, Aldor is a better choice, especially in Sunwell Plateau phase where it offers better value.
Priest
Healer
The difference between Aldor and Scryers for Healer is extremely limited. Aldor's shoulder enchantment is slightly better numerically, but there are many alternatives, so the difference isn't significant.
Therefore, you can choose based on your preference.
Shadow
For Shadow, Aldor is the better choice. Aldor's shoulder enchantment offers significantly higher spell power than Scryers, making it the best choice for Shadow in the current version.
If you don't choose Aldor, you'll have to settle for Zandalar Signet of Mojo, but this isn't ideal in The Burning Crusade, as nobody wants to go back to Zul'Gurub.
Rogue
For Rogues, choosing either faction doesn't significantly impact raid performance. The main difference lies in the choice of shoulder enchantment.
Aldor's Greater Inscription of Vengeance is slightly better than the Greater Inscription of the Blade, but the difference is negligible. However, Aldor also provides a Vindicator's Brand when Exalted, while Scryers offers Plans: Enchanted Adamantite Belt, which significantly reduces the upgrade cost of Blacksmithing.
Overall, Aldor is better in terms of damage output, while Scryers is more cost-effective. You can choose based on your specific situation.
Shaman
Elemental
Elemental has almost no strict requirements regarding faction selection. Aldor's shoulder enchant is better, but Scryers offers excellent rings and a powerful trinket, Scryer's Bloodgem.
Considering the price of reputation materials, Scryers offers better value for gold.
Enhancement
Enhancement is similar to Elemental. Aldor has a slight edge in shoulder enchantment, but the difference is minimal. Scryers' leg option, Retainer's Leggings, has some value in the ancient game of TBC Classic, with relatively lower economic pressure.
Restoration
Restoration leans towards Aldor. Aldor's shoulder enchant, Greater Inscription of Faith, is better than Scryers' Greater Inscription of the Oracle. Neither faction has any worthwhile BoP items.
Warlock
Affliction Warlocks don't have a decisive difference in faction selection. Scryers' trinkets and rings offer better hit adjustment in the early game, while Aldor's shoulder enchant is slightly better in terms of damage output.
Even in Phase 5 with Shattered Sun Pendant of Acumen, the difference between the two factions is not significant, and there will be more gear options available then. Overall, this is a choice that can be made entirely according to your preference.
Warrior
Protection
Protection is one of the very few specs that clearly favors Scryers in the late game. While the difference in shoulder enchantment is almost negligible, in Phase 5, Scryers' precision procs offer superior threat generation and survivability compared to Aldor.
Furthermore, Scryers boasts more cost-effective exclusive Blacksmithing plans, saving a significant amount of WoW TBC Classic Anniversary gold when upgrading your profession. Moreover, because there are fewer players in this faction, less gold is required to reach max level, making Scryers highly recommended.
Fury/Arms
Both specs heavily emphasize DPS, so faction selection is crucial.
If you have enough TBC Classic Anniversary gold to upgrade your Aldor reputation to Exalted early in the game, you can obtain the powerful pre-raid off-hand weapon, Vindicator's Brand.
Scryers, on the other hand, has an advantage in Blacksmithing costs and the price of upgrade and reputation materials.
In reality, after TBC Classic begins, joining either faction won't provide a real advantage. Your proper choice is either to spend a lot of gold to acquire Vindicator's Brand for an immediate and powerful power boost, or to save up to improve your reputation and upgrade Blacksmithing. The decision is yours.
Ultimately, whatever you choose, understanding your class, spec requirements, and game goals is paramount. Hopefully, this guide has provided some inspiration. Now it's your turn to decide your stance.











